Traditions are never a hundred percent traditional. And no, that’s not some vague aphorism I found in a fortune cookie.
What
I mean is that traditions always have their core elements, plus a bunch
of tacked-on personal or family elements that customize them, make them
ours. Let’s use Thanksgiving as an example, since most of us are still
so crammed with pie we can’t stand up without the aid of household
furniture.
Thanksgiving
has its own baseline features that are consistent across most families:
Turkey, stuffing, orange- and brown-colored side dishes, and that one
cousin who gets tanked on Merlot and belts out “White Christmas” during
halftime of the Lions game. These are all niceties that go back to the
early days, when European pilgrims and Native Americans gathered to
feast on hearty food and complain about Detroit’s offensive line.
From
there, traditions vary. Maybe your family members dig out the old
plastic Christmas tree from the basement and decorate it while their
gastrointestinal systems try to make sense of what just happened. Or
they break out the Monopoly board and devolve into fisticuffs in a
dispute over Park Place. Every home is different.
In
Maison Lagasse, Christmas begins as soon as the last drop of beer is
drained from its mug. This is due primarily to my mother, who begins her
holiday shopping in February and would keep candy canes stocked in her
cupboard year-round if it were in any way socially acceptable. Eyelids
drooping after a gut-busting gorge, she pops in a favorite yuletide
classic -- which for the past several years has been “The Polar
Express,” an animated romp that scores points for a Santa Claus who
looks like a lumberjack in an L.L. Bean catalogue. My father quaffs
Heineken and endures this yearly ritual with relative grace while Mom
fights back tears and sings along with the musical numbers in an off-key
falsetto. I find myself stuck somewhere between these two extremes,
moved by the film’s earnestness but finding myself desperately in want
of a clear drink with an olive in it. Sometimes tradition requires
endurance. And booze.
Our
particular rituals are as comfortable and well-worn as old sweatpants,
but to members of another clan our little idiosyncrasies may seem
strange. In millions of living rooms across the country, disparate
families are up to their own shenanigans. Judging from the stories
people have shared online, many of these activities are of the “Aww, how
heartwarming” variety, which makes sense because if you’re lucky
Thanksgiving is an “Aww, how heartwarming” kind of holiday. (As opposed
to Halloween, where the overriding sentiment is “Please, children, don’t
leave flaming bags of poop on my front porch.”)
One
woman shared her family’s tradition of having a “Thanksgiving tree,”
which initially struck me as an unnecessary indoor plant in a season
already rife with them. But this is a laminated paper tree; throughout
the year, everyone in the family writes down something for which they’re
thankful on fall-colored construction paper leaves and puts them in a
box. On Turkey Day they tack the leaves up on the Thanksgiving tree and
read them aloud. Nice stuff. Another woman said she cooks food based on
recipes in her late grandmother’s cookbook, working from handwritten
text in her relative’s shaky scrawl. These traditions are so sweet
they’re almost sickening, the kind of stuff you see people doing in
Lifetime Original Movies with corny titles like “When Caroline Learned
to Love Again.”
Not every tradition is quite so saccharine, though. One man, sharing his story on the website pgeveryday.com,
said that he and his family have a gun battle every Thanksgiving. They
use toy guns, naturally; if they used real ones, each subsequent
Thanksgiving would just get lonelier and lonelier, until a day 10 years from now
when it’s just one sad man ripping into a turkey in a backwoods motel
while evading the cops. His family’s rule, apparently, is that as long
as you’re old enough to hold a toy gun, you’re a part of the
make-believe melee -- no points, no rules, no winners. Just a bunch of
people wagging around plastic Glocks and spraying each other with water
while fighting off the encroaching drag of meat-sleep.
Bizarre as that is, there’s one tradition I find even stranger. On danoah.com,
one family said that after they’re finished noshing on squash and pie,
they all engage in a game of hide-and-seek … with their cars. The gang
piles into four or five vehicles, with one car labeled the “it” car, and
the rest all seek a quiet place in town where they can park, turn off
the lights, and avoid detection; the last undiscovered car then becomes
the “it” car, and around they go again. This one gets major props for
creativity, but I’m still left wondering what the locals -- not to
mention the local police -- think of a bunch of people huddling in cars
in the dark in random neighborhoods. Has anyone’s hackles ever been
raised? Hopefully these automotive hide-and-seekers don’t live in the
same town as the gun-battling family, or else it’s only a matter of time
before someone gets a plastic firearm stuck in their face. “Happy
Thanksgiving! Now freeze, sucka!”
Goes
to show that repetition is all that’s required for something to be a
tradition. It can be the goofiest thing in the world, but do it enough
times and it’s as ingrained as the natural human instinct to punch a
clown.
This
year my intent was to start a new Thanksgiving tradition of not eating
so much blueberry pie that I temporarily go blind. Can I repeat this
year after year? Possibly. But someone may have to hold a plastic gun to
my head.